Jessica
Looking for expert pet advice? WeLovePetz is here to help you.
The Blue Buffalo Experiment: A 4-Month Journey with the Homestyle Can
A data-driven, personal chronicle of feeding my dog this popular wet food. The hype, the reality, and the science of the sniff test.
My dog, Rocket, is a 50-pound mutt with the appetite of a finicky poet and the digestive system of a delicate houseplant. For years, mealtime was a negotiation. He’d stare at his kibble like it had offended him, eat half, and walk away. I tried different dry foods, toppers, broths. Nothing stuck. The vet said he was healthy, just “particular.”
Then I saw the Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe Variety Pack—the one with “real meat first” and “no by-products” splashed across the can. It looked like human-grade potted meat. It was expensive. But the promise of a picky eater solution was too strong. I bought a pack, armed with a notepad, and began a four-month experiment. This is the report.
The Product Under Review
If you’re facing the same picky eater standoff…
VIEW THE VARIETY PACK ON AMAZON(This is an affiliate link. I bought my first pack at the pet store, but I now subscribe here for convenience.)
The Methodology: How I Tested
This wasn’t just dumping food in a bowl. I tracked three key metrics over 120 days:
- Palatability: Did he eat it? How quickly? Any “walk-aways”?
- Digestive Response: Stool quality, frequency, gas. (Yes, I became that person.)
- Physical Indicators: Coat shine, energy levels, weight maintenance.
- Versatility: How did it perform as a topper vs. a full meal vs. a treat?
I used it three ways, as the label suggests: 1. Mixed with his old kibble (50/50). 2. As a standalone meal. 3. As a high-value training treat.
The Timeline of Results
Phase 1: The Topper Trial (Weeks 1-4)
I started by mixing a quarter can into his rejected kibble. The result was immediate. The rich, meaty aroma (it smells like potent liver pâté) brought him to the bowl instantly. He ate everything, licking the bowl clean. This was the first win. Digestively, no issues. Stools were firm. The “no corn/wheat/soy” claim seemed to hold for his sensitive gut. The gravy coated the kibble perfectly, making it irresistible.
Phase 2: The Standalone Test (Weeks 5-8)
Confident in his acceptance, I fed a full can as dinner. He devoured it. However, I noticed he drank less water afterward—a good sign of high moisture content. At the vet check-in, his weight was stable. His coat, which was always decent, seemed to have a noticeably brighter sheen. Was it the Omega fatty acids? The high-quality protein? I can’t prove causation, but correlation was there. The variety pack prevented boredom; he showed no preference between chicken and beef.
Phase 3: The Training & Long-Term Use (Weeks 9-16)
This is where the versatility shined. A pea-sized amount on a spoon became the ultimate recall reward—more effective than store-bought treats. As a long-term diet, the results held. Consistent eating, healthy digestion, great energy. The “real meat first” promise felt tangible. When I compared the ingredient list to a cheaper wet food, the difference was stark: Chicken, Chicken Broth, Liver, Carrots… vs. Meat By-Products, Water, Wheat Flour….
The Evidence-Based Pros
- Picky Eater Kryptonite: The palatability factor is not marketing. The aroma and pâté texture are incredibly effective for hesitant dogs. Our mealtime standoffs ended.
- Digestive Peace: For a dog with a sensitive stomach, the absence of common fillers (corn, wheat, soy) and by-products resulted in perfectly consistent, healthy stools. Zero digestive upset over four months.
- Observable Coat Health: While not a miracle, Rocket’s coat developed a healthier, shinier look that multiple people commented on. The nutrition was visibly effective.
- True Versatility: It genuinely works as a topper, meal, and treat. This flexibility makes it worth the price; it’s three products in one.
- High Moisture Content: The reduced water intake signaled good hydration from the food itself, beneficial for urinary tract health.
- Ingredient Transparency: The label is clean and understandable. You know what you’re feeding your dog.
The Practical Cons & Considerations
- The Cost is Substantial: Feeding this as a full-time diet to a medium/large dog is a significant monthly expense. It’s a premium product with a premium price.
- Pâté Texture Isn’t for Every Dog: Some dogs prefer chunks or shreds to lick. Rocket loved it, but texture preference is real.
- Storage & Mess: You must refrigerate leftovers. The pâté can be sticky and greasy on utensils and bowls, requiring a good wash.
- Calorie Density: It’s rich. Portion control is essential to prevent weight gain, especially when using as a topper on top of regular kibble.
- The “Natural” Debate: While far better than many, it’s still processed canned food. It’s not the same as fresh, home-cooked meals (but it’s also infinitely more convenient).
- Can Size Inconvenience: For a single small dog, a 12.5oz can is too much. You will have leftovers to manage.
Answering the Critical Questions
Based on the ingredient list and the observable results (smaller, firmer stools often indicate higher-quality, more digestible protein), yes. The first ingredient is deboned chicken or beef, not a meal or by-product. In the world of commercial dog food, this is a meaningful distinction.
It’s free from common allergens like corn, wheat, and soy, which is a great start. However, if your dog has a specific protein allergy (e.g., to chicken), you’d need to avoid that flavor. It’s not a hydrolyzed or novel protein diet, so for diagnosed severe allergies, consult your vet. For general sensitivities, it’s an excellent option.
Yes, it is formulated to be 100% nutritionally complete and balanced for adult dogs. My vet confirmed this. I did it for two months with no issues. Ensure you’re feeding the correct amount based on your dog’s weight to meet their caloric needs.
This is just Blue Buffalo being transparent about updating their can design. The food inside is identical. I received cans with both old and new labels during my subscription; the content was consistent in smell, texture, and Rocket’s reaction.
The Final Analysis: Is It Worth The Investment?
After four months, 48 cans, and meticulous observation, my conclusion is a cautious but confident yes.
The Blue Buffalo Homestyle Recipe delivered on its core promises: it enticed my picky eater, provided excellent digestive comfort, and supported visible overall health. The versatility added significant value, allowing me to use one product for multiple needs.
The high cost is the most significant barrier. However, when I factored in the reduced waste (no more half-eaten kibble), the elimination of other toppers/treats, and the priceless peace of mind at mealtime, the economics shifted. For Rocket, it wasn’t just food; it was a behavioral and nutritional solution.
If you’re struggling with a picky or sensitive dog, and your budget allows for a premium wet food, this variety pack is a scientifically-formulated, highly effective place to start. It may not be magic in a can, but in my household, it was the next best thing: reliable, healthy, and finally eaten.
Recommendation: Start with the variety pack as a topper. Observe. Let your dog’s bowl—and their health—give you the final verdict.
Consider starting with a single pack to conduct your own two-week trial. The proof, as they say, is in the licked-clean bowl.
Disclaimer: I am a passionate pet owner with a background in research, not a veterinarian or animal nutritionist. Rocket’s experience is unique to him. This article is based on my personal, documented observations over four months and is for informational purposes only. Always consult your veterinarian before changing your pet’s diet, especially if they have underlying health conditions. This article contains affiliate links, meaning I may earn a small commission if you purchase through them at no extra cost to you.
Authors
